What Our Clients Are Saying
At Kingsway Realty, we take pride in delivering exceptional service and guidance throughout the buying and selling process. But don’t just take our word for it—hear from our satisfied clients who have trusted us with their real estate journeys. Their experiences speak to our commitment, expertise, and dedication to making every transaction as smooth and successful as possible.
I want to take this opportunity to thank Carl Unruh for all his help in my recent move. He explained things clearly and took the time to answer my many questions. As we went from room to room to prepare for the showings, he knew exactly what to do and guided me throughout the entire process. Whenever I called him, he was quick to respond. The day before closing, he explained what would transpire. I am so appreciative of all his help and will gladly recommend him as a realtor to my friends and neighbors.
– Betty Kreider
Kingsway is wonderful.
We worked with Anita Stoltzfus in particular, and I can’t say enough great things. She’s professional, kind, extremely prompt with communication- just a dream to work with (both buying and selling). She’s the kind of realtor who truly has your family’s best interests at heart.
– Kelcy Waller
Wendy just gets the job done. She’s thorough, professional and let my best interest lead her every move. She’s not pushy or salesy at all. Works with integrity and very hard and still is compassionate and personable. She has been doing this for many years and it shows in her expertise. Having worked with other agents in the past, she is now my go to for all future purchases and sales!
– Krystal E.
My realtor is Andrea Madonna. Andrea handled everything from start to finish. We looked at 26 houses until I found “the one”. Andrea was tenacious and hard working, a very good communicator, and helped with every single question and step in the process. I cannot say enough good about her work ethic and expertise.
– Rissy Allen
I met Barbara Cavanaugh 20 years after retiring from the Police Force in New York. She sold us our first home here which we still live in. She has also closed several deals on rental properties we had owned. We found Barbara to be one of the most knowledgeable realtors in the area with years of experience. She also is a person of excellence and integrity.
– B. Medina, Jr.
Working with Rob Hess was an absolutely amazing experience from start to finish! From our first conversation to closing day, they were professional, responsive, and genuinely invested in helping us find the perfect home. Their knowledge of the market, attention to detail, and strong negotiation skills made the entire process smooth and stress-free. They were always available to answer our questions, explain next steps, and offer honest advice — we truly felt like we had someone in our corner the whole way. Rob went above and beyond, whether it was scheduling last-minute showings, connecting us with trusted inspectors and contractors, or just checking in to make sure we felt confident every step of the way. We couldn’t be happier with our new home at Parkside at Lampeter and our experience, and we wholeheartedly recommend Rob Hess to anyone looking to buy or sell. A true professional and a pleasure to work with!
– Nate Brenneman
We worked with Jen Thomas at Kingsway for the purchase of our new home and the sale of our old home and she was great! She helped guide us through the process, was always available when we needed her, set up staging, and got us what we were hoping for for both new and old! Highly recommend!
-Heather Valudes
Kelly Reber is fantastic at her job. We highly recommend her. She is professional at all times and always willing to go the extra mile for you. She is responsive to all questions and makes the process of buying a home so easy.
-Leslie Gawthrop
Just bought my first house at 31 yo. Didn’t know much about anything. Decided to use Kingsway Realty. They did a great job of making the experience as pain-free and seamless as possible. Would highly recommend.
– Patrick Balandiak
We recently worked with Kingsway Realty to list and sell our mother’s condo. They made what seemed to be a complicated transaction as simple and straightforward as possible. We were led step by step through the entire process from listing to closing, and Kingsway made it a pleasurable and profitable experience for us. No doubt we would use them again.
– The McD Family
We bought a house 4 years ago Kingsway. Then we purchased a house this year Kingsway Realty. I would highly recommend Kingsway based on our experiences with them.
– Jesse K, via Google Reviews
We never felt pressured to spend more than we felt comfortable with, were given plenty of resources to assist us, and had all of our questions thoroughly answered. Made our first home buying experience awesome!
– Nicole R, via Google Reviews
I have used them for every transaction since the purchase our first home. They are the largest and the best local company in the area. They are very professional and very knowledgeable!
– Jason B, via Google Reviews
Start Selling Your Home Today
Ready to sell your home? Our experienced agents are here to guide you every step of the way, from pricing and marketing to closing the deal. Get started today—connect with a Kingsway Realty expert and take the first step toward a successful sale!
We’ve Got Tools
Make informed decisions and navigate your buying and selling real estate journey with confidence by utilizing our selection of tools below: